The cloud-funded retailer against the grocery-anchored one — increasingly the same fight from opposite directions.
AMZN and WMT are converging: one built retail and grew a cloud and advertising business on top, the other built stores and is bolting e-commerce, marketplace and advertising onto them. Both now earn a meaningful share of profit from something other than selling goods. The comparison comes down to where the profit actually originates and how much you are paying for the part that is not retail.
Online retail and logistics at enormous scale, with AWS and advertising supplying most of the operating profit.
The largest physical retailer in the world, increasingly combining stores with e-commerce, marketplace and advertising.
Group margins mislead in both cases. What matters is how much profit comes from cloud and advertising versus from selling goods — the mix, not the total.
The most direct head-to-head number available, and the one that shows whether the incumbent retailer is genuinely closing the gap online.
Retail is an operations business. Turnover shows who is converting shelf space into cash fastest, independent of how the story is told.
Both spend heavily — one on data centres, one on stores and automation. Cash left after that spending is the honest basis for comparing them.
Neither is valued as a retailer. Look at what cloud and advertising contribute to each, and ask whether the remaining retail operation would justify anything close to the rest of the price.
Grocery-weighted retail is defensive; discretionary online retail and enterprise cloud budgets are not. The two businesses respond to a weak consumer in genuinely different ways.
Educational only. Not investment advice.
A free account charts one company on one metric over the last five years. Putting companies against each other — up to five, on up to four metrics, over their whole history — is part of Ultimate, and every new account gets it for seven days: create an account, confirm your email, and the trial starts without a card. A chart is an address, so the link you made keeps working the day you subscribe.
Type up to five tickers onto one canvas — any listed names, not just the pairs on this site. Each company keeps its own colour on every chart.
Choose up to four metrics. Two share one chart with an axis each; more split into a panel per metric. Statement figures sit on each company’s own fiscal dates, so a quarter is never stretched to look like a day.
Open a company’s page for its Quality Score, its intrinsic value and its fair value, save it to a watchlist, or export the chart as an image. The whole chart lives in its link, so it can be bookmarked or sent.
By revenue it is mostly retail; by operating profit it leans heavily on AWS and advertising. That gap is the single most important thing to understand before comparing it with a conventional retailer on any margin metric.
Its e-commerce growth and use of stores as fulfilment points have narrowed the gap in convenience, particularly in grocery. Whether that translates into profit is best judged from segment margins and the advertising business rather than from growth rates alone.
Grocery-weighted retail tends to hold up better than discretionary spending, but cloud revenue is contracted and reasonably resilient too. Compare the revenue mix directly rather than relying on the label.
Comparing companies is part of Ultimate · 7-day free trial included · No credit card to start