The same category, the same weather, the same housing market — separated mainly by who walks through the door.
HD and LOW sell broadly the same products into the same housing market, which makes the customer mix the whole comparison. Home Depot skews toward professional contractors, who buy bigger baskets more frequently and keep spending when consumers pause. Lowe’s skews toward do-it-yourself consumers and has spent years closing the operating margin gap. Because the external drivers are identical, differences in comparable sales and margin are unusually informative about execution.
Home improvement retail with a large share of sales to professional contractors alongside consumers.
Home improvement retail weighted more toward do-it-yourself consumers, with a multi-year effort to win professional share.
Both face the same housing market and the same weather, so a persistent gap in comparable sales is a genuine signal about execution and customer mix.
The clearest measure of the historical performance gap and of whether the margin improvement programme is actually landing.
Professional customers spend more per visit and are steadier through a slowdown. Mix explains most of the difference in results between these two.
Retail is a capital allocation business — new stores, inventory, distribution. ROIC shows who converts that capital into profit most efficiently.
Both depend on housing turnover, mortgage rates and home equity. Compare how each performed through the last rate cycle before assuming either is defensive.
The narrower of the two margins is the whole bull case for the challenger. Track it quarter by quarter — if the gap stops closing, the case weakens regardless of valuation.
Educational only. Not investment advice.
A free account charts one company on one metric over the last five years. Putting companies against each other — up to five, on up to four metrics, over their whole history — is part of Ultimate, and every new account gets it for seven days: create an account, confirm your email, and the trial starts without a card. A chart is an address, so the link you made keeps working the day you subscribe.
Type up to five tickers onto one canvas — any listed names, not just the pairs on this site. Each company keeps its own colour on every chart.
Choose up to four metrics. Two share one chart with an axis each; more split into a panel per metric. Statement figures sit on each company’s own fiscal dates, so a quarter is never stretched to look like a day.
Open a company’s page for its Quality Score, its intrinsic value and its fair value, save it to a watchlist, or export the chart as an image. The whole chart lives in its link, so it can be bookmarked or sent.
Home Depot has historically run a higher operating margin, largely because of its professional customer mix. Lowe’s has been closing the gap, which makes the trend more interesting than the level — compare both directly.
Both are, through housing turnover and home equity borrowing. The consumer-weighted business tends to feel discretionary weakness first, while professional demand from committed projects holds up somewhat longer.
Because they face virtually identical external conditions. When two retailers share a market, a category and a season, differences in comparable sales and margin come down to execution — which is exactly what a side-by-side comparison isolates.
Comparing companies is part of Ultimate · 7-day free trial included · No credit card to start