Two integrated majors with the same commodity input and meaningfully different portfolio shapes.
XOM and CVX both live and die by the oil price, which means the comparison is not about who benefits when crude rises — both do. It is about break-even costs, portfolio balance and balance-sheet resilience: who keeps generating cash at a low price, who has to borrow to defend the dividend, and how much of the business sits downstream where cheap feedstock cushions the blow.
An integrated oil major spanning upstream production, refining and a large chemicals business.
An integrated major with a more upstream-weighted portfolio and a long record of shareholder returns.
The single most important number for an oil major: the price at which it covers capital spending and the dividend without borrowing.
Downstream and chemicals behave counter-cyclically to crude. The mix explains why two majors report different results from the same oil price.
Commodity downturns are survived on the balance sheet. Leverage entering a weak period determines who buys assets and who sells them.
Production depletes every year. Replacement shows whether the business is sustaining itself or quietly liquidating.
Any oil major can carry a high yield at the top of a cycle. The question is which can still fund it at a low crude price without adding debt — that is what the break-even tells you.
Refining and chemicals dampen the swings in both directions. A more upstream-weighted portfolio gives more torque to a rising oil price and more pain in a falling one.
Educational only. Not investment advice.
A free account charts one company on one metric over the last five years. Putting companies against each other — up to five, on up to four metrics, over their whole history — is part of Ultimate, and every new account gets it for seven days: create an account, confirm your email, and the trial starts without a card. A chart is an address, so the link you made keeps working the day you subscribe.
Type up to five tickers onto one canvas — any listed names, not just the pairs on this site. Each company keeps its own colour on every chart.
Choose up to four metrics. Two share one chart with an axis each; more split into a panel per metric. Statement figures sit on each company’s own fiscal dates, so a quarter is never stretched to look like a day.
Open a company’s page for its Quality Score, its intrinsic value and its fair value, save it to a watchlist, or export the chart as an image. The whole chart lives in its link, so it can be bookmarked or sent.
Both have long records of defending their dividend. The meaningful test is the free cash flow break-even oil price and net debt — a dividend funded by borrowing at low crude prices is a weaker dividend, whatever the yield says.
The one with the greater upstream weighting, since refining and chemicals margins often improve when feedstock gets cheaper. Compare segment earnings to see how each portfolio is actually balanced.
That depends on your view of long-term demand and on the discipline of capital allocation. In the meantime, the financial question is measurable: break-even costs, reserve replacement and leverage through a full cycle.
Comparing companies is part of Ultimate · 7-day free trial included · No credit card to start